Monday, July 15, 2019

I. OPENING SESSION


The workshop opened with welcome messages from FAO, AsiaDHRRA and the Vietnam government, followed by a group photo and the introduction of the workshop participants.

Welcome Message by Mr. Nguyen Song Ha, Assistant FAO Representative (Programme), Officer-in-Charge, FAO Viet Nam

Mr. Ha emphasized the role that investments in agriculture play in the eradication of hunger and poverty and importance that these investments are “responsible.” Mr. Ha also reiterated the commitment of FAO to promote responsible agricultural investments through the Principles for Responsible Investment in Agriculture and Food Systems (CFS-RAI) in the light of vast amount of investments coming into the Southeast Asian region. He also discussed the importance of empowering the youth to engage in agricultural activities to create livelihood opportunities, achieve food security and stimulate economic growth in the CLMV region.  He mentioned that key challenges that need to be addressed include limited access to land and credit.

Welcome Message by Dr. Nguyen Xuan Hong, AsiaDHRRA Chairperson

Dr. Hong thanked FAO for giving AsiaDHRRA the opportunity to be part of the first discussion of CFS-RAI in the Southeast Asian region.  He also expressed agreement with the call for an increase in investment in agriculture but also cautioned that these investments should result in the “3Ps” or triple bottom line -- that investments not only produce Profit but also benefit the People (the rural poor in particular) and protect the Planet. Dr. Hong also issued the challenge among the participants to address the need to get more young people engaged in agriculture and to have more “investments for the youth, and by the youth.”

Opening Remarks by Dr. Nguyen Nhu Cuong, Acting Director, Crop Production Department, Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development

Dr. Cuong described the agriculture sector of Viet Nam as not yet significant in terms of share in GDP as it accounts for only around 15% of the country’s GDP.  However, he noted that the impact of the agriculture sector to the country is “deep” as it employs almost 48% of the population and affects almost everybody.  It is for this reason that the government of Viet Nam places significant attention and support to the agriculture sector.  Dr. Cuong mentioned that Viet Nam has various policies on attracting direct foreign investments in agriculture, including a decree on bank credit for the agriculture sector.  He also mentioned that the government has a program for sending technical experts to Japan for training on the latest agricultural techniques and technologies.  He also expressed agreement with the importance of attracting the young college graduates to work in the agriculture sector.   He mentions that the Minister for Agriculture has emphasized the need to expose students to agriculture enterprises.  He also said that the government is targeting the establishment of 15,000 cooperatives by 2020.


GROUP PHOTO


II. PROGRAM REVIEW/OVERVIEW OF CFS & ASEAN GUIDELINES ON RAI


Mr. Michael Riggs, Capacity and Development Officer, FAO Rome

Mr. Riggs went over the objectives and expected outputs of the workshop. Mr. Riggs then proceeded to describe the state of “underinvestment” in the agriculture sector in Southeast Asia and that FAO estimates a total additional annual investment of US$265 billion is needed to eradicate global hunger and poverty by 2030.  Of the said amount, US$ 140 billion in investments in agriculture and rural development is needed. Next, he enumerated the reasons why more investments in agriculture are needed and why these investments need to better also. Mr. Riggs then discussed the CFS guidelines on responsible investments in agriculture (CFS-RAI), including its 10 principles.  Mr. Riggs also pointed out that the CFS-RAI gives priority and importance to small-scale producers, including family farmers, and that the said principles are voluntary but not legally binding.  He also discussed the important role that young people play with regard to agricultural investments.


Ms. Marlene Ramirez, Secretary General, AsiaDHRRA

Ms. Ramirez presented the overview on the ASEAN Guidelines for Responsible Investments in Food, Agriculture and Forestry.  She mentioned that the guidelines are necessary to maximize the development benefits from the expected rise in investments in agriculture (due to increasing demand for food) but, at the same time, minimizing the risks associated with such investments.  She also explained the difference between the CFS-RAI and the ASEAN Guidelines on RAI as the latter was adapted to the ASEAN context with greater emphasis given to technology and innovation, climate change and natural disasters, regional approaches, and home/host country dimensions. Finally, she enumerated the action plans of Grow Asia, ASEAN, FAO and IISD on how to promote and operationalize the said guidelines. 

III. CHAT SHOW ON YOUTH AND AGRICULTURAL INVESTMENTS


A panel of four speakers were asked to speak before fellow participants and share their experiences and initiatives regarding the youth’s role in agricultural investments and development.

The first set of speakers, Mr. Duong Nhu Mung, a member of the Cooperative for Agricultural Production and Services from Vietnam, discussed the needs of the youth sector to be able to engage and benefit from agricultural investments, and Mr. Him Noeun, Project Manager of Farmers and Nature Net and Coordinator of CamboDHRRA.

The second set of speakers, Mr. Soukaseum Bodhisane, representing the private sector, is Director of the Lao Farmer Product (LFP), and Dr. Htet Kyu, representing CSOs, is the Land Policy Advisor of GRET Myanmar, discussed the services their respective organizations provide to youth sector.   

Mr. Mung, a farmer and member of a cooperative, shared that they produce seedlings, livestock, tea and oranges.  He cited as one of the main problems that prevents them from expanding their business or operations is the inaccessibility of credit due to numerous requirements and high interest rates.  He also cited access to market information (i.e. what products are in high demand in the market, where can their products be sold, etc.) as a key need for farmers.  Another need he cited was access to better production technologies.

Mr. Nouen of Farmers and Nature Net, shared that Cambodia has a large labor force but has been decreasing mainly due to competition from other sectors (i.e. industrial sector) and migration to other countries to find better opportunities. 

Mr. Nouen cited the following services they provide to their farmers:

a)     Capacity building/training in “agricultural techniques” for rice, vegetable and fruits production and processing;
b)    Organizing members into production groups and then linking them with private companies that serves as buyers of their products;
c)     Assistance in the marketing and packaging of their products; and
d)    Assistance in accessing credit/capital.

Mr. Nouen also enumerated the following needs of farmers, especially for the young ones:

a)     Greater access to affordable credit (i.e. low or zero interest);
b)    Incentives and support for young farmers who go into new agribusiness ventures;
c)     Marketing support; and
d)    Development of vocational/”hard skills” (i.e. “agricultural techniques,” food processing, accounting, etc.); and “soft skills” (i.e. communication skills, people skills and community relations/organizing skills).

Mr. Bodhisane, shared that LFP is a small agribusiness enterprise that buys raw materials (mainly organic rice and tea) from small local farmers that they have trained and formed into organizations, and then “commercialize” these products (i.e. processing, packaging and marketing).  LFP provide officers of the partner farmers’ organizations technical trainings in business management, accounting, organic standards, the 10 principles of organic farming and processing, proper storage and transport of their produce. In addition, LFP also provides the farmers organizations zero interest and zero collateral loans to finance their infrastructure, equipment, and funds for buying the produce of the farmers, and cover 50% of the very high cost of organic certification.

Mr. Bodhisane also cited the following difficulties they are facing:

a)     Their product is not competitive because of the very high cost of transportation.  He cited that the cost of transporting their products from Vientiane to Bangkok is equivalent to the cost of transporting to Europe; and
b)    Access to local credit remains very difficult.  The reason they can provide zero interest and zero collateral loans to their partner organizations and also why they mainly export their products to Europe is because of their access to pre-financing from European.

Dr. Kyu shared their experience in two regional projects he is involved with.  The first project is the Agro-Ecology Learning Alliances in Southeast Asia to form a strong network among small holder farmers in Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar and Vietnam to support the introduction of sustainable agriculture farming methods as an alternative to the existing and dominant chemical-dependent system of farming.  Dr. Kyu also shared their major finding that majority of the farmers that are practicing sustainable agriculture or organic agriculture are young farmers.  Thus, with the second phase of the said project, they will focus on the young farmers.

The second project is the Mekong Regional Land Governance Project which involves land tenure security for small holders and ethnic/indigenous peoples.  The project involves working with and providing support to certain civil society organizations and farmers organizations who are involved in the advocacy for land governance, in particular the recognition of customary/traditional tenurial practices in the upland areas.  It also involves the formulation of guidelines for responsible investments in agriculture to avoid “land grabbing” or the displacement of small holder farmers by big investors.

Dr. Kyu also expressed surprise with the existence of the CFS-RAI or of guidelines focusing on the role of youth with regards to responsible investments in agriculture.